RA FOR ALL...THE ROAD SHOW!

I can come to your library, book club meeting, or conference to talk about how to help your readers find their next good read. Click here for more information including RA for All's EDI Statement and info about WHY I LOVE HORROR.
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query gnooks. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query gnooks. Sort by date Show all posts

Friday, March 12, 2010

RA Resources for All: Gnooks

In the past I have mentioned one of my favorite RA resources for when I am completely stumped: Gnooks.  You can click here to see the other posts where I have talked about this unique resource.  But for those of you who cannot tear your self away from this current post, here is a basic Gnooks primer.

Basically, Gnooks is a computer generated list of author readalikes. People input authors they like and don't like and the gnod engine uses its trademarked algorithm to create a visually stunning display of similar authors.

When you type in "Stephen King," you get this. Each of the authors you see floating near King's name can also be clicked on. That author is then made the center of his or her own map. The visual representation of how author's works may be near one and other is very useful to patrons; however, since these maps are completely computer generated, I do not like to trust them as my only resource when assisting a reader.

They do however help you the librarian, especially if you have no idea who an author is. It literally places him or her on a map where you or your patron may see other familiar authors. It is also a good resource to use to check your other findings against.

So why, you may ask am I revisiting Gnooks in today's post? Well, I am also grading student midterms right now, and one, Bethany wrote this about Gnooks in her paper:
I like to think of Gnooks as a compass. It's won't tell you how to get home, but it'll keep you from getting lost.
I think that perfectly describes how Gnooks can help you. Go type in your favorite authors right now. If you are not happy with what you find, you can change the results by entering the authors you like and don't like. The more people who participate and input their preferences, the more useful Gnooks gets.

Wednesday, July 15, 2009

ALA Report- From the Book and Beyond: Interdisciplinary Readers' Advisory

Beginning with this year's annual conference, RUSA will now have an annual RA Research and Trends Forum. This year it debuted as the RUSA President's Program. If this program was an indication, we will be very lucky to have such a wonderful RA specific program offered at every conference from now on.

This year's program featured three speakers and was entitled "From the Book and Beyond: Interdisciplinary Readers' Advisory." Here is the link with more details.

First up was Nathan Altice, a musician , digital artist, and adjunct professor of sound communication at Virginia Commonwealth University. Altice talked about the brain, technology, and musical appeal. He focused his talk on Pandora, the for-profit (but free to end users) Internet radio station where users can create customized play lists based on computer generated recommendations.

Pandora makes it recommendations based on the "Music Genome Project." A group of musicians and music professors got together and analyzed thousands of songs, creating 400 plus appeal terms (click here to see them all). The founders of Pandora then created a proprietary algorithm that matches the appeal terms with certain songs; creating "listen alikes."

I was familiar with with Pandora, having used it and been amazed at how well it does, but I had no idea how it worked until now. Altice's main point was that this works only when people and machine work together. To paraphrase him, humans are best at assigning meaning and the machines can do the computations, "the digital muscle needs human intervention."

Altice's program made me think about how we make suggestions to readers. Generally RAs shy away from computer driven recommendation engines. But ones for books like Gnooks, do serve their purpose at times. For example, I use Gnooks when I have no idea where on the literature map an author is. Click here for a literature map on Charlie Huston to see what I mean. The point is, there is a human/machine interaction that makes these recommendation engines at least worth taking a look at. Also, I found the discussion of how Pandora breaks down appeal and then applies it in a mathematical way very intriguing.

From music, the discussion moved on to Steve: The Museum Social Tagging Project and a presentation by its founder Susan Chun. Basically, this project has taken many of our country's museum's digital collections and opened them up for the public to describe them. Chun, who at the project's start was at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in NYC, was noticing there was a huge semantic gap between the catalog records and how regular people describe (and as a result) search for materials.

T0 make a long story short they wanted to see if allowing social tagging would help users find art more quickly, change the ways users engage with the museum, and help museum curators understand what their visitors see? So they let people start assigning words to their pictures online. They found that 88% of the users tags were relevant. But now they are trying to sort out the "noise" of too many tags. They are also working on a way to determine whether or not a specific tag is useful.

I was keenly interested in Chun's findings because in our library system, we have begun the switch to a new interface for our catalog (Encore) in which library patrons will be able to start tagging books. The hopes are for it to have the same success as Steve, replacing outdated subject headings like cookery with the more likely term, "cooking," to be tagged by end users. I will continue to follow the Steve Project as we get closer to beginning our own system wide social tagging project.

Finally, Nora Rawlinson from Early Word: The Publisher Librarian Connection came on to talk about the results of a publishing industry study (the Codex Study) as to what makes people want to pick up a particular book. Notice she didn't say what made them buy it. The publishers first need people to pick up their book before they can move toward making a purchasing decision. She then took each reason and talked about how libraries can use that information.

The top reason (63%) was that it was by a favorite author. Libraries have this covered with our standing order author lists and our extra copy plans. But, Rawlinson did mention that this should remind us to always ask readers who their favorite authors are.

Second place was a tie between the Genre of the book (48%) and the Flap Copy (48%). Genre is no shock to librarians. We all have genre collections, but the Flap Copy importance was big news. Usually publishers give that job to the lowest person on the totem pole, but now they are starting to take flap copy more seriously. She even gave us a few examples of flap copies that are beginning to contain readalikes (for fans of...). Librarians should learn from this more journalistic writing style in selling books to readers.

The findings rounded out with 29.4% going for Cover Art and Design and 23% who were drawn to the book's title. (Obviously people could pick more than one thing.)

Rawlinson wrapped up with a few final thoughts. When we are buying for the library should we consider book jackets, and how? Libraries could use flap copy for shelf talkers to draw out books lost in the stacks. She also suggested that librarians read some of the ugly covered books to see if they are worth reading. If they are, we could jazz up the covers or put shelf talkers right on the books themselves.

As you can see it was a very thought provoking program. As an experienced Readers' Advisor, I liked how this program made me think outside of the box. Can't wait for DC next June.

Wednesday, December 9, 2009

Wrap-Up Class

Tonight I had my "wrap-up class." This is the last lecture of the semester in which I try to summarize everything we have learned in the past few months and tie up any loose ends.

We have a few exercises, but we also discuss the entire semester's worth of discussions happening on the listserv for Readers' Advisors, Fiction-L.

New for this semester, I have created a handout of the the 10 things you cannot leave leave this class without knowing. It is modified from a new 60-75 minute talk I have been giving at libraries focusing on how all staff can provide basic RA service, or as I like to call it RA for All. Catchy, no?

Anyway, here are Becky's Ten Rules of Basic RA Service:

1.) Betty Rosenberg: “Never apologize for your reading tastes.”
2.) Suggest don’t Recommend.
3.) Everyone reads a different version of the same book.
4.) Write down adjectives about what you read; plot you can find.
5.) Read widely (at least speed read widely).
6.) Read about books (RSS feeds).
7.) Share what you read- with staff and patrons.
8.) Never let a patron leave unsatisfied.
9.) Get out from behind the desk.
10.)Get involved in creating displays.
I also provided a list of the 5 RA resources you cannot live without. Here is the text from the handout:


Plot summaries, possible read alikes, but most importantly, customer comments! 5 star and 1 star reviews are the most helpful.
NoveList: EBSCO Database
Most helpful quickly-- Left Hand Menu: Recommended Reads; Right Hand Menu: Genre Outlines. Enter author or title and look for “Author Read Alike” or “Feature Articles” tabs.
Kent District Public Library’s What’s Next Database: http://ww2.kdl.org/libcat/WhatsNextNEW.asp
Easy to retrieve and print lists of books in series order. Makes patrons happy. Brings them back!
When you are desperate…distract them.
My blog which talks about all things Readers’ Advisory.

So this is the super quick version of what we have spent all semester talking about. I also go out to libraries and teach this extremely basic "RA for All" class, so contact me if you are interested in having me come to you.

Thursday, September 20, 2007

RA Party Game?

Whenever I go out to give a RA lecture/training I always end with the following fun web site, called Gnooks. As decribed on the site, "Gnooks is a self-adapting community system based on the gnod engine. Discover new writers you will like, travel the map of literature and discuss your favorite books and authors."

Basically, it is a computer generated list of readalikes. Although I would not trust this site to provide the perfect suggestion for your next good read, the aqua browser display employed by their "map of literature," is attention grabbing.

When you type in "Nora Roberts," you get this. Each of the authors you see floating near Ms. Roberts' name can also be clicked on. That author is then made the center of his or her own map. The visual representation of how authors works may be near another's is very useful to patrons; however, since these maps are completely computer generated, I do not like to trust them as my only resource when assisting a reader.

There are librarians trying to do these reading maps in a slightly different format and with their expertise behind the readalike suggestions. Take a look at these two samples by Neal Wyatt. This is professional RA on the web in a truly interactive format. It is dynamic and exciting for the patrons and well as being fun for the librarian to create.

Thursday, April 26, 2018

RA Conversation Starter: Ask Your Patrons About Their Favorite RA Resources

When I talk about RA Service I stress that listening to our patrons is juts as important as suggesting books to them. Why, because one of the main tenants of RA Service is that "everyone reads a different version of the same book."

Reading is personal. You and I may both like the same book, but it could be for completely different reasons, and those reasons could even be diametrically opposed. This is something I talk about in detail and for which I give real life examples when I present, but the point here is that we need to understand WHY the person in front of us likes the books they like before we start trying to match them with a specific book.

However, I also know from experience that getting patrons to talk about the books they like and why is hard. We need to have ice breakers to start the RA conversation AND get them to reveal their reading preferences beyond specific authors and titles-- to get at what is appealing to them about the books they love.

So, here is a great conversation starter to use with patrons-- ask them to tell you what resources they have used in the past to find books to read for themselves. Their answer tells you more than you think about their reading preferences.

First, there is the obvious reason to do this, you can go straight to that resource and look for more titles. For example, if they say "NPR," you can go to the NPR books site and start talking with them about the books that have recently appeared there. You don't need to have read these titles because the info is all there. Also, the brand new titles are on the front pages, but they do an excellent job of providing many backlist options, especially through the Best Book Concierge. [Here is a post I have written just about that resource].

But you can do this with any resources. Go to their favorite first and talk about why they like it and how they use it. Together you can find more titles, but at the very least, you are setting the example that RA Service is about talking about books in a effort to find a good read. It is both the conversation and the transaction.

Second, you can learn a lot about the type of book someone wants by their answer to the resource question. For example, the person who answers "best seller lists" or "recs from friends," that patrons is interested in the communal aspect of reading. They are looking for titles that other people are reading, enjoying, and talking about. You need to keep that in mind as you help them find other books to read.

People who answer with a very specific genre based resource, well for those people you have found out that they love a specific genre. You will start the conversation with that genre.

You get the point. The key take away here is that these examples focus on getting the conversation started. You might not find them a viable suggestion immediately this way, but you can get the patron talking about the books they like more easily. Asking people to articulate why they like the books they like without them ever having thought about this before will stump most people. Heck, it stumps many of you when I ask you to do it in my training sessions. Also, I have found that they aren't as open about their true preferences if this question makes them nervous. They start spouting things they have heard others say about books and reading trends.

On the other hand, when we take the focus off a specific book and instead ask them how they have identified those good reads, we can start talking about the discovery process. It is in that process where we hear the WHYs. It is that process where we excel. It is that discovery process which we can facilitate for them.

We can even introduce them to a few fun resources in the process too. I really love Gnooks Literature Map as a way to spark conversation without pressure. Here is the entry for Gillian Flynn. When patrons see all of the authors those who liked Flynn also like, they will understand that everyone likes books for different reasons because the list is so varied. For example, I never thought of Kevin Kwan as a readalike for Flynn until I went here. Seeing that someone else likes both made me think about it and now I totally see it [engaging characters, high drama are shared. Tone, not so much.]

Seeing this connection that no other resource would make, together you will both will feel less pressure and talk about more authors and titles they have loved and why-- even those that don't seem like they make sense. Plus you can click around and end up somewhere no other resource will take you.

So ask your patrons to tell you about their favorite book discovery resources and see where the conversation takes you.

For more ideas, here is a link to the other posts I have tagged "Conversation Starter."

Monday, January 24, 2011

Monday Discussion: What Should I Read Next?

For today's Monday Discussion, I wanted to get more into the nitty gritty of how we help patrons.  Every day we librarians who are providing service to leisure readers are asked to help our patrons find their next good read.  My library has only been open for 1 hour and I have helped 3 different patrons in this manner already!

I know what resources I use to help patrons, but I want to know what you use when trying to match readers' tastes with a book in your vast holdings?

For me, I have a few go-to resources.  I always go to NoveList first.  On NoveList, I can pull up the book, reviews, its subject headings, often some appeal terms, and possible a list of read-alike options (for full disclosure, some of these are ones I have written).  I like how I can go with the read-alikes mentioned in the reviews or those provided by the NoveList content writers.  However, I just as frequently pull out a specific subject heading or appeal term and run a wider search.

My second favorite resource is Amazon.  I treasure the customer comments on Amazon as a vital resource.  Why? Because I see these comments as actual patrons, talking to me about the book.  I can see what real, average readers, not reviewers, felt about the book.  This information is priceless since a non-professional reader is who I am helping. It is also important to note that the most extreme views, both 1 and 5 stars, are the most helpful.  These point out what readers felt passionate about on either side of the debate.

I also often use Fantastic Fiction for its compilation of the books an author has recommended his or her fans read.  This info is at the bottom of most author entries.  I like All Readers for their detailed and frank delineation of sex and violence.  Click here for sex and/or here for violence and scroll down to the boxed descriptors, specifically under the heading of "Style" to see what I mean.

And finally, when my mind has gone blank, I show patrons the aqua browser maps of gnooks.  Here is the entry for Stephen King.  Sometimes, this computer generated list, gets both my brain and the patron's jump started and the ideas start flowing.

I think this last suggestion brings up an important point.  Matching readers with their next good read is a collaborative experience.  I do not use any of these resources in a vacuum.  I am constantly talking about what I find with the patrons, using that information to ask more questions, and then finally using the answers to do more searching.

Of course, there is also experience.  After 10.5 years of providing RA service, it sometimes comes down to the fact that there are books I have suggested to similar readers in the past and know they worked.  But using the resources is also of building that experience.

Now it is your turn.  What are your go-to resources for helping match readers with their next good read?

And remember, you can follow past Monday Discussions here.

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

While You Wait...

Today at work I am focusing on my Friends of the Library Duties and will not have a post until tonight.  But while you wait, why not amuse yourself over on Gnooks.

Type the name of your favorite author into the literature map and see what you get. Please note, this is a computer generated suggestion engine; it is no match for the super hero also known as you local public librarian (especially super if you come to the BPL RA desk).  The results can range from spot on to absolutely ridiculous, with all options in between included.  But no matter its accuracy, I guarantee a fun time.

Here is the map for one of my favorites, Michael Chabon.

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Why Can't These People Go To a Library?!?!

I am so upset I don't know if I can write this post.  Yesterday I came across this article on the NYT website, talking about GoodReads acquiring the automatic reading recommendation website, Discovereads.

Discovereads bills itself as having the best book recommendation system online.  I'm okay with that.  They do it online, with an algorithm; no people involved.  But then I get to the user comments further down the page, and I have to admit, I may not be able to control my anger:

This site helps me discover new books I would never have known about, based on my previously read and liked books! It takes all the headache out of looking for a new book to read once I've finished my present story. My only problem is choosing between all the interesting reads suggested!
- Emily Y.
I like Discovereads! It gives me great book recommendations that really fit me.
- Audrey W.
I've had a lot of difficulty finding books in the past, but after spending a little while on your site, I now have thirteen potential reads.
- Jeffrey L.

HAVE THESE PEOPLE NOT HEARD OF THE LIBRARY!!!!!  Sorry for the caps, but I am not happy here.  From where I sit, these comments are ridiculous.  They are thanking a computer for helping them do something that an actual trained person can help them do either in-person, over the phone, or over the computer through the local library.  Oh, and that actual person can get you the actual  books in print, audio, or ebook format...for free!!!

Audrey, we have book suggestions that fit you at the library.  Jeffrey, you would not have had trouble in the past if you had called us, at your local library, first, and Emily, we are all about preventing headaches at the RA desk.  You just need to remember that trained people exist to help you.  If the three of you could have seen the diverse group of people I helped to find their next good read just yesterday alone, you would be singing the librarian's praises, not some algorithm's.

That is not to say that computer generated suggestion sites like Discovereads or Gnooks do not have a place in the RA world.  In fact, they are a great option when you are stuck for ideas, but nothing beats talking to a trained readers' advisor about your reading tastes.  Quite often readers cannot articulate why they like a certain book.  They need to be asked specific questions about why they liked the pacing, storyline, characters, mood, style, and language.  From their answers, the RA librarian can begin to craft suggestions.

Also, these resources do not take the most important RA interview question into consideration..." Are you in the mood for that or something different."  Meaning, just because I gave a book 5 stars on a website a week ago, that does not mean that I want another book exactly like it now.  Maybe I want something completely different.  How is the computer going to figure that out?  No one reads the exact same type of book over and over.

The point is, a trained librarian can do a much better job than a computer.  And, you could contact us online too.  Don't agree?  Ask me to help you.  See if I can do better than the computer.

Monday, July 11, 2011

Things to Know

Although I usually only post the Monday Discussion on Mondays, I have too many things to pass on to wait for tomorrow.

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

RA for All Roadshow: Crime Fiction

Today from 1-4, I will be presenting a training session on Crime Fiction. As part of my commitment to being "green," I do not provide paper handouts.  Therefore, this post will serve as the "handout" for today's presentation.  That means everyone gets full access to my resource list.  Please note: this is now the most up to date of my crime fiction lists.


Murder and Mayhem @ Your Library
Crime Fiction  Reader' Advisory

Becky's Favorite Crime Fiction Resources:

Books

Web
Becky's Favorite Mystery Resources:

Books
Web
Suspense, Romantic Suspense, Thriller, Adventure, and Psychological Suspense Resources:

Books
True Crime Resources:

Books
Awards for Crime Fiction Books in All Genres Mentioned Above:
Award lists, both the winners and nominees, are a great way to identify popular and critically acclaimed novels and authors for your crime fiction fans. Many of these awards include a category for best debut.  This is an excellent resource for your readers who claim they have already read "everything."
Becky's 5 RA Resources You Cannot Live Without:

  • Amazon: Plot summaries, possible read alikes, but most importantly, customer comments! 5 star and 1 star reviews are the most helpful.
  • NoveList: EBSCO Database: subscription required, check your local library.
  • Kent District Public Library’s What’s Next: Easy to retrieve and print lists of books in series order. Makes patrons happy. Brings them back!
  • Gnooks: When you are desperate…distract them.
  • RA for ALL: where you are right now