I have 2 reviews in the June 2026 issue of Booklist. As usual, these posts contain my draft review with bonus appeal into and more readalikes.
By Hannah F. Whitten
Aug. 2026. 432p. Run For It, $30 (9780316579537).
First published June 1, 2026 (Booklist).
Best-selling fantasy writer, Whitten, dives head first into Horror with a compelling, unsettling, and entertaining sea monster tale. When she was a teen, an accident at sea killed Claire’s parents and younger sister, but she has found comfort with her fiance Elias, that is, until he drops dead at work. When his mother contacts Claire and invites her to their ancestral home, a castle built into the cliff of an island in Maine, for a funeral, she accepts. As Claire enters the home and descends into its living spaces, deep underground, it begins to feel like there is something much more nefarious planned. Claire’s repressed emotions and memories add a level of disorientation to the story, but as more secrets are revealed, the pressure builds, the force breaks everything open, and the terrifying truth floods all that stands in its way. A novel not just for fans of sea soaked dark fantasy and horror, but also for readers of Gothics with immersive settings and intense dread like Mexican Gothic by Moreno-Garcia and tales of the monsters behind the business success of the uber rich like Fiend by Katsu.
Three Words The Describe This Book: Sea Soaked Horror, Gothic, Intense Unease
Further Appeal: horror about the uber wealthy, rich families with a monster secret to their success, an unreliable narrator who knows they are unreliable because of past trauma, Lovecraftian, disorientation-- the entire house is built down into the water. That was cool and makes everything about this Gothic mansion on the seaside feel even more unsettling. Readers and Claire are disoriented from the start.
Solid pacing– details revealed slowly but steadily and in a realistic way.
Title is good (a container for holy relics- to secure them from public viewing) because it hits on a few levels within the story Whitten is telling.
Whitten is a Best Selling author for her fantasy books. This is a Horror title that will definitely appeal to dark fantasy readers, but it is Horror so that needs to be made clear to readers.
While I was reading this I was also am writing my LJ Horror Genre Preview, and "seas soaked horror" is one of my trends. As I went through the books coming out over the next few months, there are a lot. I am excited because the books are literally dripping with dread and fear and it is great for readers.
Claire is a damaged and unreliable narrator from the start. We know she lived through an accident as a teen-- on a boat-- that killed her whole family. We know that she lives her life purposely pushing her feelings down and not revealing the truth even to herself let alone her therapist. This she tells us. That means as readers we are already uncomfortable and know we cannot trust her but Claire is also very sympathetic because our distrust is not based on her nefarious behavior. We trust she will share her truth as the story goes on.
We only have Claire's perspective on all of this. We know as much as her, but we don't know what she is hiding from herself.
And the sharing is well done here. The details we are given, all begin to matter and as Claire admits to herself her connection to the sea the other parts of the story start to fall into place.
Her fiancé dies and she is called to meet his parents-- uber wealthy for generations. They have a submarine company. It is well known. She has not met them, but they want her to come to have a funeral for Elias. He dies mysteriously, just dropped dead, and his brain was full of holes the doctors said. Also his strange large sea creature in their giant aquarium died as well.
When she gets there things are strange. She is led into a castle built on an island (where the road to get their retracts when not needed). It is perched on the end of the sea but the house is built down....so all of the living spaces are under the waterline.
The staff are odd, they have strange scars and injuries, and they are rarely seen.
Everyone is being very nice, but also strange. Elias' brother-- who shirked his responsibilities to the family and made Elias take his place, and the spaces of the other siblings all are trying to get her to leave of her own volition. But she is happy to be accepted, even if they are weird, and wants to belong.
The scene is set perfectly to go from uneasy and disorienting to all out terror and a desperate attempt for her to save herself. And this is all at the start.
The monster, its hold on the family, and the resolution are all satisfying. The terror is mixed with some sweetness and Claire's background and issues from thought out her life all play a part in the conclusion which I appreciated.
Whitten's story is solid and it will bring a lot of her fans to Horror. That makes me excited.
Readalikes: I picked two for the review above, but there are definitely more. For readers who love sea monster stories in the vein of the EXCELLENT upcoming A Plagued Sea by Kim Bo-young.
But also the confusion and disorientation of a family that clearly has a monstrous secret and they want the MC to pay a physical price for them like in Midnight Rooms by Coles or even Now You're One of Us by Nonami. And finally, I could not stop thinking about Alma Katsu's Fiend (mentioned above) and the demon behind the immense wealth and success of the family featured there.
Lovecraft’s Brood: Nineteen Tales of Cosmic Horror
Ed. Ellen Datlow
July 2026. 302p. illus. Tachyon, paper, $18.95 (9781616964627).
REVIEW. First published June 1, 2026 (Booklist).
Completing the duology she began with Lovecraft’s Monsters, award-winning editor Datlow is back with 19 previously published stories, all from this century*. An impressive list of authors focus their talents on cosmic fear as Lovecraft defined it– an immersive, existential dread, steeped in the realization that the universe is indifferent to our suffering. The range of stories includes those firmly grounded in reality such as Paul Tremblay’s “The Note,” where a neighborhood walk leads to a wife’s disappearance; to a tale caught in the space between realities– the roadside motel– as in Wendy Wagner’s “Halogen Sky;” to a tear in the fabric of reality, caused by a kitten, in T Kingfisher’s “Agent of Chaos.” Each story begins with an illustration by John Coulthart, perfectly capturing the appeal of the story to come. A great choice for longtime Lovecraftian Horror fans and newcomers alike, yes, but this volume will also lure readers in with the promise of a tale by a beloved author, as they exit having discovered a few new favorites along the way.
*This is always important to point out in these Lovecraft anthos. We want to be clear these are TODAY’S voices.
Three Words That Describe This Book: Cosmic Dread, anthology, madness
Further Appeal: John Coulthart -- illustrations-- the illustrations before each story are a nice touch. They are like an interpretational drawing to summarize the story. Not just the plot but the appelr as well. This is a very nice touch.
This is the second in a dulology. The first was Lovecraft's Monsters which focused on exactly that-- monsters from his mythos. But here, we have 19 previously published stories-- all from the 21st Century-- but names you know well, some a little, a some, not at all. This time, focusing on cosmic fear as Lovecraft defined it and then showcased in his works.
Datlow's introduction plainly and clearly defines this Lovecraftian brand of fear that leads to madness, all steeped in the realization that the universe is indifferent to humanity and that the human mind cannot comprehend the truths that make the vastness of the universe tick, that to peer behind the veil of our perceived reality will break you-- your mind and body.
These are Cosmic stories. They plant their profound dread into the reader's body. Existential terror grows out from our guts and infects our minds.
Too often "Lovecraftian" stories or anthologies don't explain in plain terms what is going on, what the intention of this work is. There is a bar to entry for novices when it comes to all things "Lovecraftian." It keeps new comers out. This anthology welcomes them in and paired with the first one-- Lovecraft's Monsters it serves as a great introduction to Lovecraft's legacy.
Some of my favorite stories are "The Note" by Paul Tremblay where a couple goes on a walk, the wife reads the note on a neighborhood door, and then the next day disappears. It is told from that point on as the husband (a Tremblay stand in) suffers from not knowing what happened and what the note even said.
Wendy Wagner has a great take on the weird roadside hotel off the interstate trope
But one of the shortest is also my favorite. It is by T Kingfisher entitled "Agent of Chaos." and it is best set up by its perfect first sentence, "It was a blustery day in November when the kitten accidentally ripped open the fabric of reality." Just read it.
Readalikes: Read the first anthology as well and search out work by the people in the top here. Any Datlow anthology is a great readalike.
There are plenty of titles that capture the spirit of Lovecraft but are by 21st Century writers who are aware of the problems with the man and actively engage with that in their stories. Growing Things by Tremblay, Stories from the Motel Sick by Michael Allen Rose– very much the same vibe. In the Mad Mountains: Stories Inspired By H. P. Lovecraft by Joe Lansdale as well.






