
Library Trends 75(2), November 2026, "Rethinking Readers’ Advisory for Today’s Reading Reality."
Everything is tagged "Library Trends", so you can use that link to pull up the features of each article and its authors in reverse chronological order here. Or you can use the page I have created for this entire issue to read any article at any time. All of it is open source and free through Project Muse.
Today it is the fourth article in the issue. But before I get to that, I also want to note that this article is also the final one in Section I, “Laying the Groundwork for Twenty-First-Century Readers’ Advisory Service,” which features four articles that establish the foundation upon which we believe twenty-first-century readers’ advisory service should be built. The authors in this section look at service to readers from theoretical and educational perspectives.
pp. 309-332
Abstract: Readers’ advisory (RA) starts with a healthy, well-curated collection. Collection development is obviously fundamental to RA service. Selecting materials is the “wholesale” end of the “retail” marketing RA transaction. Just as weeding is a vital part of the life cycle in a popular materials collection, weeding is also necessary to provide exceptional RA service. This article will start with weeding fundamentals, then share processes for weeding nonfiction and fiction popular materials collections for youth or adults across print, audiovisual, and then e-books and e-audio formats developed through years of experience.
Karen Toonen has spent a lifetime reading library books and revering both school and public libraries, but her formative years included a lot of disdain for librarianship. Librarians always seemed to gatekeep books as “beyond grade level” or “not good literature.” In 2001, Toonen discovered librarians dedicated to readers’ advisory and the course of her professional life changed forever. Working for five years as a readers’ advisory assistant at Indian Prairie Public Library confirmed her interest in pursuing librarianship as a career. After obtaining a master’s degree from the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, she began working for Naperville Public Library. Toonen also assumed leadership roles within the Adult Reading Round Table, an organization centered in Chicagoland and devoted to developing readers’ advisory skills and promoting reading for pleasure through public libraries. After twelve years as an adult services librarian, Toonen moved into technical services when collection development centralized. In 2020, she became collection services manager, reopening the department after the COVID closure. Toonen has presented extensively on weeding and other collection development aspects at the regional, state, and national levels.
Toonen is THE current American expert on weeding. Even Rebecca Vnuk, author of The Weeding Handbook, agrees. Toonen manages the second-largest circulating collection in IL. She has a background in Readers' Advisory so 1, she understands the intimate connection between collection development and RA, but more importantly, 2, she understands that weeding is an essential part of collection development and is not afraid of it, rather she embraces how weeding popular materials (the correct way) can make the patron experience better.
Toonen's super power when it comes to weeding is that her undergraduate degree is in math. Unlike many library workers she not only likes math, she understands how to use it to make collection decisions. But unlike many mathematicians, she is also well versed in serving patrons, so she also understands that some decisions about weeding are not simply a matter of following the data blindly.
When Robin and I had our call for papers for this issue, we reached out to Toonen and asked her if she would please consider being a part of this issue. I am so glad she said yes.
Please click through to read Toonen's article here through Project Muse for free (just verify you are a human) or check out my page for Library Trends 75(2).










